I am a comic book nerd. I'm especially a DC nerd. Recently, DC Comics decided it was going to re-start 52 of their comic titles at issue #1. To non comic book nerds, this is a huge deal. Going back to square one means erasing decades of history. For example, Superman is not married to, or even dating, Lois Lane. A character who used to be Batgirl before the Joker shot and paralyzed her, is back to being Batgirl and running around like nothing happened.
DC Comics says they have done this to streamline their stories and attract new readers. They felt the histories and back stories to many of their characters were so heavy, that new readers were intimidated to start reading. Personally, there were titles I never picked up because I felt I had to read 20 years worth of back issues to understand the plot of this month's issue. From that standpoint, I understood what they were trying to do. They went out and got the best writers and artists and told them to build the best stories you can for our readers. That is to be applauded. Trusting the experts to create amazing content. Good for them.
Another thing DC Comics is doing is embracing the digital realm. They are releasing their books in the stores and to digital devices at the same time. In the best you had to wait weeks before a title would be available. Now, you can download and read right away. I love this. I got home and downloaded Justice League and read it right away. DC Comics feel that comic book shops are getting hard to find and they can be intimidating to new readers. Digital downloading opens up their product to a whole new audience.
The relaunch of the 52 began yesterday with the release of Justice League. It is awesome. The art is amazing and the story is going to head somewhere exciting.
Now, what can this DC Comics have to do with education? Everything. I feel that the state of education is in the same place right now. There is so much baggage being carried around by trying to maintain the status quo, we are scaring away people from education. We can no longer try to fix what ails the system one book at a time. Much like DC Comics has done, it might be time to relaunch education as a whole. Really strip it down to the bare bones and go back to what worked best and look at the ways we deliver our content.
I know that is easier said than done, but how long can we try and fix a broken system until we get to the point where we stand there confused with our hands in the air. I do not claim to have all of the answers, but I have lots of questions. How long do we wait until it is realized we need a wholesale change and not a bunch of minor fixes?
I applaud DC Comics for taking a major risk in starting from scratch. I am hopeful to see some amazing stories in the near future and I hope their actions lead to more changes in comics across the board.
As for education, do you think we need to start from scratch or can we still save the system we have?
I would love to hear your thoughts.
var _gaq = _gaq || ;
ga.src = ('https:' == document.location.protocol ? 'https://ssl' : 'http://www') + '.google-analytics.com/ga.js';
var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script'); s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga, s);
In a way I agree. Finishing the book Death of Common Sense where he discusses the way law has built up this impenetrable wall of stupid and the only way to fix it is to restart. I like your analogy, starting from scratch may be a decent idea.ReplyDelete
Awesome post, and it is a risky move for those that have been highly invested in the old system that DC had. Totally applaud what DC has done lately. I've been a Marvel guy first for years, but I find myself reading some of my DC books before Marvel ones, now. There seems to be more focus and a real desire to tell a great story. Marvel seems to be telling good, short stories over a long period of time.ReplyDelete
But onto the education part, there are so many entities entrenched in the current system, be it educators, admins, or companies that make their money off the broken system. Why do I still have to follow the antiquated grading system in my district? Because a group of people known as the school board that really have no connection to education get to tell me what I have to do (though I often buck what they say, even with some of their kids in my classes. I'll do what is best for the kids, period, even if it means I have to deal with meetings and whatnot).
So the real question is how do we fix what needs fixed?
I think this is an excellent move for all the reasons you listed. I'm a Business/Career Ed teacher to high schoolers and have lent out out "Johnny Bunko" by Daniel Pink to some of my more apathetic, adult students. As educators, we have to continue to reach out in new ways.ReplyDelete