Saturday, January 9, 2010

Are Study Guides Extinct?

Are Study Guides extinct? Has it gone the way of the Triceratops? Will the next generation of teachers look at old handouts and think, "Are these the 'Dittos' we learned about in our Educational History Class?" Do kids actually use them to study, or are they just filling in blanks to receive a few points. Here's my journey that ended up with the burial of Study Guide use in class. 

As a bright eyed teacher ready to change the world, I needed a way to ensure that students would read the assigned material and note important facts along the way. A set of questions designed to lead students to answers that will help them later on for the test. Now, I did not invent this concept. My teachers gave us study guides from time to time and I did what many students did, copy what my friends did or grab the answers from the Cliff Notes. As an English teacher now, it's a tad bit embarrassing. Like many English teachers, I was not counting down the days until I could teach To Kill a Mockingbird while cruising through high school. I thought I would outsmart some of my students by creating questions that had answers that could not be found in Cliff Notes or Spark Notes. I was trying so hard to make kids learn, that I was creating an environment in which no learning was happening. A game of Cat and Mouse would be played between students who do not want to read and a teacher that is trying to find ways to get kids to read. What to do?

My next step was to use more analysis based questions. Create longer study guides by having students discuss important aspects of the story and use literary terms they have learned to dissect the story. Well, it seemed like a great idea until I received the first batch of completed questions. Many students were completing the assignment, but they were all spitting out the exact same answers that we were discussing in class. It was nice to know they were paying attention in class, but they needed to start creating their own answers from the material read and the discussion we were having. Again, I was at a loss. I would try to create a balance with some fact based questions and more analysis based questions to split the difference. Last year, the game was about to change.

As time passed, I was still looking at ways for students to demonstrate knowledge of the text and analysis of ideas discovered in the text. Creative projects were used from time to time. I love having students create comics for stories they read because they have to place emphasis on the aspects of the story they decide to keep in and explain why they edited some parts out. It goes over well, but many of my students are not artistically inclined. Other forms of expression were attempted, but nothing seemed to be attractive to all of the students in my class. Two school years back, my school started to use to check for Plagiarism. We already had a nice policy in place for Plagiarism (Read my last post for more info.), but technology had opened up a world of information to students that were starting to use in school, but not cite appropriately. The Plagiarism check is a wonderful program that I suggest to all schools to look into and I will talk about it in a later post, but they also a discussion board. This is what I was looking for.

I have used discussion boards for a few years in my college classes and on various web sites. I never really considered using it with high school students. The main reason was that I did not have the means to set up a Discussion Board for 150 students. However, now that I had the means, all I needed was the will, and I had plenty of that.

I started off slow and started to use the Discussion Board with my Honors students only. I placed a few questions for the students to answer and allowed them a week to answer. One of the requirements for each question I posted was that they answer my question in 5-6 sentences and that they respond to a fellow student in 3-4 sentences. The biggest problem I encountered was that many students waited to the last minute to respond to the question and forced the most proactive students to wait until other responded. To remedy this, I offered extra points to those first two students that would answer the question to encourage those to start early. That solved the problem quickly. The improvement in recall has been amazing. Students are taking the question I post and answering it fully, but the comments they are making on other students' remarks are incredible. The act of synthesis is a tough one for many students. DB's offer students a chance to create their own answers based on the answers of others. No longer to they feel compelled to spit out the same thing I talked about in class. Here is a great example,

Here is a comment from one student on another student's answer to the initial question. Below is a comment on the above comment. The discussion was growing before my eyes!

Not only were kids demonstrating that they were doing the reading, but they were creating their own questions for others to answer or forcing students who might not agree with them to support their counter argument. What more could a teacher want in a discussion. The exchange of ideas was happening outside of the classroom. One of the biggest surprises was still to come.

The thing that I noticed most after implementing DB's was the voice of the quiet student. The kids in class that normally have nothing to say and avoid eye contact when you ask a question were some of the most prolific DB participants. They seemed excited to offer their voice to the discussion. Perhaps the fear of ridicule was preventing them from answering. On the DB, they are free to answer and know they can do it safely from their computer. The middle of the road kids might be hesitant to challenge the "A" student in class, but have no problem taking aim over the computer. Not only that, the positive feedback they receive on their comments has started to translate in the classroom. The feel more confident that their peers will respect their answers. They no longer avoid eye contact, but strive to be in my line of sight. DB's have changed my class culture in a positive way.

One last positive about the use of DB's is the amount of paper that I have saved my school. An average Study Guide would be at least 3-5 pages long depending on the size of the novel. If I had 3 sections of a class reading the same book and an average of 30 students per class (No joke), then I'm looking at over 200 pages per study guide. Times that by the 5-6 novels we read in year and that's 1,200 pages per year for only 3 classes! That doesn't seem like very much, but you add the rest of my department that uses SG's and the other teachers in the school that use them as well, and the number of pages is astronomical. The Green aspect of DB's is another great reason to use them. 

I asked if Study Guides are extinct. Perhaps they are not extinct, but maybe they have evolved. They were great for a time when students needed to rely on the book and the book alone for all of the answers. With a world of information and short cuts available to them, it is important to use this new world to teach and be innovative.  DB's have brought a more complete learning to my students. They are creating new ideas and sharing them with each other outside of the classroom. As a teacher, these are the things you dream about. I have taken many lessons away from the road to the Discussion Board. It was a long journey, but it is not over. I hope the future educators will learn from these relics and create better tools for their students.


  1. Interesting blog. I came across a site you may wish to try for discussions on books. BookGlutton. Don't know the security issues at your school, but you might take a look.

    Susan Brooks

  2. Thanks! I'll look into that on Monday. Have a great Sunday. :)

  3. A discussion board is a great way to get students involved. I noticed the same thing with my elementary kids. When given an online venue to discuss a topic, those who are generally to shy to participate, jump right in and share. They go back and forth with each other and truly discuss and challenge each other to think critically. It is neat to witness kids come out of their shells like that. Bravo on the evolution of the study guide!

  4. Nick,

    Thanks for the post, I will be sharing this with my teachers ASAP. I have been pondering the worth of mid-terms as well and I think this all ties together. We want more authentic experiences for our students and you are doing some great things. Thanks for sharing!

  5. Thanks Patrick. It's nice to see that Admins are taking an interest in changing the culture of education.

  6. Sounds interesting, and I've done a little of this in the past, but I do have one question, which is about workload. My students already have lots of work and are already stressed, and I worry about giving them one more assignment. Did you cut out anything when you added the DB assignment? Or is it short enough (and engaging enough?) that it's not a problem?


  7. Nick,
    Thanks for sharing your experiences and success. You have confirmed a few things that I have read about the great benefits of using a discussion board with students. I was drawn to your post because of the Study Guide reference because I have added a virtual copy of my exam study guides online ( using a wiki. The results were similar to your experience with the discussion board as the students ran with the idea and took it further than I expected. As I prepare for our second semester to begin in two days, I will now add a discussion board thanks to your post!

  8. David,

    Thanks for the comment. Work Load is always on my mind. I have students that are in multiple honors classes and AP classes. I think that DQ's are less work for the students as they read a novel. With a SG, the students might have to do more searching in the text for specific information, while a DQ allows the students to take the ideas from the reading and formulate their own answer.

    I always tell students that I love English Classes because there are no wrong answers as long as you can support your idea with evidence for the text. This allows some creative thinking in the DQ's instead of misc. facts from the text.

    The length of the DQ's are up to the teacher. I've given 3 Q's in a given week and they have the week to respond. They are far more engaging than a SG. The discussion I've seen between normally quiet students has been very interesting. I've often pulled some of the ideas presented on the DQ's and used them as a springboard for further discussion. I think that is the big part of using the Discussion Board. Teachers need to bring the conversation back in to the room, or else it's not much better than a SG.

    I hope this helps. Feel free to email or tweet me if you have more questions. @TheNerdyTeacher

  9. Tom,

    I'm glad to hear you are going to give the DB's a go for the 2nd semester. It's never easy to incorporate new tech into lessons. It's so easy to be comfortable with your lessons and move right along with what you have always been doing.

    I really like what you did with your wiki. I've been playing with the idea of doing something similar with my students as well. If I can get it to look like yours, then my kids will be in store for some great learning.

    Thanks for the comment. Keep educating the youth of tomorrow. :)


Please post your thoughts here. Thanks!